---
title: "Tamettant n yiɛaḍalen"
description: "Tuget n uxeddim aɣarmi d aderwic n yimedyaten gar iprezidenten. AI txeddem aderwic ifazen ugar n imdanen, syaqar, raxs, yerna 24 ssiɛa i ass. Billable hour yekfa."
canonical: https://www.askgib.com/kab/articles/the-end-of-lawyers
last-updated: 2026-03-23
lang: kab
---
# Tamettant n yiɛaḍalen
> Tuget n uxeddim aɣarmi d aderwic n yimedyaten gar iprezidenten. AI txeddem aderwic ifazen ugar n imdanen, syaqar, raxs, yerna 24 ssiɛa i ass. Billable hour yekfa.
By Gibril Bachouchi. Filed 2026-03-23. 5 min read. Web page: https://www.askgib.com/kab/articles/the-end-of-lawyers
Languages: [en](https://www.askgib.com/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [fr](https://www.askgib.com/fr/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [ar](https://www.askgib.com/ar/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [es](https://www.askgib.com/es/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [ru](https://www.askgib.com/ru/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [pt](https://www.askgib.com/pt/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [it](https://www.askgib.com/it/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [de](https://www.askgib.com/de/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [ja](https://www.askgib.com/ja/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [ko](https://www.askgib.com/ko/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [hi](https://www.askgib.com/hi/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [he](https://www.askgib.com/he/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [zh](https://www.askgib.com/zh/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [tr](https://www.askgib.com/tr/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md) · [kab](https://www.askgib.com/kab/articles/the-end-of-lawyers.md)
Tekreḍ aɛaḍal i wesmaqlal n yiwen uɛqed. Yetxellis-it $500 i ssaɛa.
Tessmaqaleḍ-t mi yelli adukamen. Yedda deg-s. Yebbest aɣwwas. Yura tasebka. Yebbest aɣwwas-nniḍen. Yura tasebka-nniḍen. S ssaɛa wis-kraḍ, yufa-d 11 n uguren, ulac ula d yiwen i kkummin sin akkenwa. Aɛqed d aksib n templatat. "Asmaqlal" d asegrer kan belli boilerplate yagh boilerplate.
Lefatuṛa tewweḍ-d. $1,500.
Asegra-a akk d aɣbel n $30 i d-yefra usawftu.
Tugna n tnezzin n usaḍuf tebnan ɣef tikti d akken asaḍuf yesseḥwaǧ asefkar n bnadem isgudden. Yerna deg *kra* n tegnatin, d tidet. Tisefrayt taɣelnayt n M and A yusilen. Asuref aɣaramni amaynut ɣer ttribunalt taɣelnayt. Aɣilif n yiɣen ɣef takebbant. Aya yesseḥwaǧ iɛaḍalen ay-izemren ad ttdamen s usnefli, ad bnun timacuhin, ad qaren texxamin.
| Anida nesseqdac iɛaḍalen tuget n wakud | Aḥric |
|---|---|
| Asmaqlal n ifecka / e-discovery | ~25% |
| Anadi aɣaramni | ~20% |
| Asuneɣ n uɛqed / asmaqlal | ~20% |
| Imegrayen d imsaɣen / awal | ~15% |
| Aban di ttribunal / depositions | ~10% |
| Asefrek / lefatuṛa | ~10% |
*Tlata tisitin tamezwarutin, azal n 65% n yal axeddim aɣarmi, d ayen ay-txeddam AI ass-a ifazen, syaqar, raxs. 35% i d-iqimen d ayen yetferwen.*
Aktem n uxeddim aɣarmi d aderwic n yimedyaten. Eɣr aɛqed, ssemtawal-it ɣer agim n yiɛqudaten ifehmen, sken iɣilifen-is. Anadi ɣef tezreft n teɣwsiwin n usteqsi yefnen, sserɣes precedent. Suneɣ wala. Suneɣ leqra. Suneɣ aɛqed n uxeddim. Asmaqlal n ifecka n discovery rnu balises ɣef wid i sɛan assaɣ d uɣilif. Sebɣes tewriqt n lḥeqq. Cegg tabrat n usuter seg umedya.
Aya mačci d asefkar aɣaramni asegmaḍ. D asefraq n umelman yenfennden. Acuɣer yeswa $500 i ssaɛa? D tikrist tukrist n medden i sɛan usrid akken ad t-xedmen, mačci d uḍuqaq amussnan n uxeddim s yiman-is.
Thomson Reuters tugh-d Casetext deg 2023 yerna tesserwel ufus n AI-nsen aɣarmi, CoCounsel, ɣer Westlaw, adagh ifazen n unadi aɣaramni di Tamerikt Tugnif. Sya ɣer 2025, CoCounsel yetwasqedac sɣur tikebbaniyin tameqranin n iɛaḍalen am Morgan Lewis d Polsinelli. Anagraw izmer ad d-iɣer ifecka akk n tegnit, ad iselɣa iɣawasen n unadi imuṭṭiyen, ad isuneɣ tigertilin, ad d-yessufeɣ tisertin n imexdamen, ad d-isufeɣ asuneɣ amezwaru n isufaɣ ifuhamen am SEC Form 8-K.
Isefka unsiben n Thomson Reuters qaren-d belli anagraw d-yefkan **asmaqlal n ifecka d usuneɣ n iɛqudaten 2.6 imuren yiziggwiren**, s **85% n iseqdacen i yettafen ugar n yisaman ifefan** ugar n wid yetwafan s ufus. Unadi-nsen yeqqar-d belli aleqdem amaḍlan n AI ad isgur **azal n 200 ssaɛa i useggas i uɛaḍal**, neɣ azal n 10% n tezmert n labur akken n tidet.
| | Ssaɛat i useggas |
|---|---|
| Anadi aɣaramni s ufus | ~500 |
| Anadi aɣaramni yetwaɛiwen s AI | ~300 |
| **Asegri** | **~200 ssaɛa / aɛaḍal / aseggas** |
*Isefka unsiben n Thomson Reuters n 2025. D taɣigit tunusiblat, tegersa belli iɛaḍalen ad kemmlen ad xedmen tuget n lxedma s tɛiwint n AI. Tagnit tameɣrant tessimɣur kraḍ n iɛaḍalen s yiwen.*
Tagatit-a tunusiblat. Tegersa belli iɛaḍalen ad kemmlen ad xedmen tuget n uxeddim-nsen yerna ad sseqdacen AI akken ad d-tɛiwen. Aneru i icudden ugar d akken yiwen uɛaḍal s AI ad iberren kraḍ iɛaḍalen mebla AI. Tanaqsa mačci 10%. D 60-70%.
Harvey AI, i yetwasqedacen sɣur tikebbaniyin tameqranin am A&O Shearman, ittxeddim aya. Akkenni Lex Machina, i d-tetfak isleḍen iẓerfen n iɛaḍalen, ttribunaten d wmcawer. Spellbook, i wesmaqlal n iɛqudaten. Everlaw, i e-discovery. Yal aẓetta n uxeddim aɣarmi ddaw n umassel yettwakles deg usawftu.
Yerna atan aḥric i ilaq ad iseḥer akk tasnaɛit: ttribunaten tura sseqdacen-ten daɣen. **CoCounsel ad iberreḥ ɛlayen i yiɛaḍalen.** Mi yelli umaḍal afeku-nni n AI am sin n tama, abbalu yedda ɣer wid n yiɣilif anida bnadem yettarna kra. Yerna tuget n tikkal, d aḥric drus n labur akk.
Billable hour yelli axaṭer d nettan kan d abrid akken ad yetwaxlleṣ umsaɣ ɣef wakud mebla ad yettwaɛhed s wnaru. Isyadan ur xelisen ara s tnaḍut. Inijiniren ur xelisen ara s ujwiḍ yetwasezzin. Iɛaḍalen sufuɣen-d s ssaɛa axaṭer asufeɣ s ssaɛa yesseggad mliḥ asentem n uɛaḍal d *ulac aselli*.
Ma kečč tetxellseḍ s ssaɛa, aɛaḍal-ik yettxellis ugar mi yedduquq ucetki. Yettxellis ugar mi yili discovery iqett. Yettxellis ugar mi llan setta n tikla n usewqem. Tasnaɛit taɣaramt tebna anabaḍ akk n tnezzin ɣef arwiḥ n ufafil.
Mi tessebḍa AI lxedma n setta ssaɛa di tlatin n tdaqiqin, takebbant tesɛa snat n tegnitin. Ad d-tefk asegri i umsaɣ, neɣ ad tessufeɣ setta n ssaɛa-nni yerna ad tesseggem aleqdem. Tuget n tikebbaniyin ad ɛerrent tukrist wis-sin. Ad teddu kra n iseggasen. Sakin amenharzaḍ seg uxeddim aɣarmi imnenni AI, s ten n umur n ssuma, ad iccaḍ ssuq.
Tikebbaniyin tisemsiyin ssnent belli ayagi i d-iteddun. Ttawḍent-d gar ad tt-bnunt s ssumat tigedlal i lxedma ɛadi. Tikebbaniyin tafarwasin mazal qaren billable hour ad teqqim i lebda. Tirubaɛ-yya ad ilint d timeẓyanin di semmus iseggasen.
**Amusnaw**, aɛaḍal s tmusni teftalt deg tasit tedmast, tin yesɛan iẓayar meqqer. Aɣilif n yiɣen di semiconductor. Tabzert gar imnaḍen di kraḍ n tiwilayatin tedmast. Tasaḍuft taɣaramt deg ttribunalt n usuref. Imukan i deg AI tt-iɛiwn maca ur tt-yberer ara, axaṭer aẓayan rxis aṭas i imaḍriyen n umelman aɣasakzi, yerna ineggura n ad teɣleḍ ẓayanin aṭas akken ad ten-tessgayrayḍ.
**Anneflu**, aɛaḍal yelan d atukrist s JD. Win yeɣɣaren imdanen, yebnu tigrumma, yefriy tinezzin. Imeggarmen n M and A. Iɛaḍalen n usallum amellal i mucalen tikebbaniyin di unadi. Ittribunalin i ttreren tigatin. Ulac kra seg-s ad t-id-yexdam usawftu, axaṭer aktem d assaɣen n bnadem, mačci d asefkar aɣaramni.
**Abennay**, aɛaḍal i isseyyaren takebbant n usaḍuf tagamant n AI. Win i d-yebnan inegrawen ay-itȟaaǧjen yiwen ad yexdem lxedma n xemstaɛec. Tikebbaniyin-a ur ttbanent ara am Cravath. Ttbanent-d am tikebbaniyin n usawftu i tt-id-fkant tisemriyin aɣaramni. S kra n wakud, ad sturent lxedma ɛadi n tasnaɛit akk.
Yal yiwen-nniḍen, acrik i ixeddmen asmaqlal n ifecka, aɛaḍal n uɛqed, aɛaḍal n tnezzut ɛadi, aɛaḍal n twacult amimal ay-ixeddmen seg umedya, aparalegal n taminbut, yettwanaɣ ɣef-s s usawftu i ifazen yakan, raxs yakan, yerna yettif tiriri ugar n nutni.
Ma kečč d bnadem i isseḥwajen tikwal ufus aɣarmi, aɛqed yelli, awsenlam, asuter amecṭuḥ, asetlef, asgar n texxamt, ifekken-ik ad lhin aṭas.
Deg 2026, tezmreḍ yakan ad tesseqdaceḍ ChatGPT neɣ Claude akken ad d-tesleḍeḍ aɛqed n umzaray yerna ad d-tessekneḍ tigertilin asutan. Ad d-iṭṭef tuget n wayen ad d-iṭṭef ucrik ilemẓi, mebla anaqib. I wayen i yif-it iẓay, tisemriyin n AI tagamant ttbanent-d, i d-iḥettmen ssuma teflayt, $300 ɣer $1,500, i lxedma yelan yeswa $5,000 ɣer $15,000.
Tasnaɛit n usaḍuf ad tegrin akin. Tigrumma n usaḍuf ad ssutren useyyaḍ n "unauthorized practice of law" mgal ifecka n AI. Kra n iɛrad-a ad ddun deg umur ageraz. Ulac wala i ad d-yeddu i lebda. Tdamsa tegguzred mliḥ. Lemkan n tmussna i d-yefkan azal i ssuma yefra.
I imsaɣen n tnezzut, alemmuden-nni yedduy s waṭas. General counsel s tirubaɛ tamecṭuḥt n texxamt yerna ifecka n AI ass-a izmer ad ixedm ayen i yesseḥwaǧan tasit n tnezzin n usaḍuf n 20 yemdanen ɛecra iseggasen aya. Tikebbaniyin tameqqra ad seg-sent kemmel uxeddim n ad-yegen-takebbant. Ad sruḥen acu ilan.
Yella yiwen ifekken-d aɣbel ay-iggugen i wsezgeẓ n AI ay-iqaren d aza.
Asaḍuf mačci kan ɣef d-tawi tiririt s tlawt. Iqersi ɣef tiririt s ttawil *yetqimen ɣef usemḥmaḥ*, deg unagraw anida ineggura n ad teɣleḍ gemmlen imdanen i ittruḥun ɣer leḥbus neɣ i sruḥen ixxamen-nsen.
Inegrawen AI ɛad d-suffuɣen ḥalucinations. Ɛad xeddmen tucḍiwin tiɣreft. Ɛad ttawḍent-en tegnitin i d-yettawi ufus n bnadem aɛaḍal. Tagnit tasebban n umuxxir n New York i isufu aɣmis i deg llant tisitumin n usaḍuf d-snulfan-tent AI deg 2023 yella d aweli amezwaru. Llant tiyaḍ syin.
Tiriri taɣiḍit ɣef ayagi mačci d "AI ur tezmir ad tetwasqedec i usaḍuf." D "AI ilaq ad tetwasqedec s lemḥasan, s usenqed, deg iẓerfen ifesren mliḥ." D nettan ad xeddmen iɛaḍalen ifazen. CoCounsel yetwabna ɣef wamek yal tiririt tetwarra deg ugbur n Westlaw i yetwasenqed, s tisitin i icudden srid ɣer wegbur n ssbab. Aɣbel n usenqed yeli i tefrat. Yesseḥwaǧ kan imdanen ad sneqden s tidet.
Asbed yegran n uɛaḍal, s tnerni, d akken ad yili d amsenqed. Ad yili d bnadem i d-yetɣar isufaɣ n AI, yetḥasab-iten d tilawt, yeçreq aɣmis aneggaru. Asbed-a d tidet. Maca d yiwen umdan deg umkan n ɛecra.
I wallafen iseggasen, asaḍuf yella d aɣawas. Aɛeggal yetwafsel. Tamusni tetwaɣbar. Aẓumar n ukcam yefka azal i ssuma.
Di ɛecra iseggasen i d-iteddun, ayagi ad yefri. Tamusni mačci d tagberberant. AI tessen yal tigent, yal asaḍuf, yal aẓetta amezgan, yal precedent. Tezreb ugar n bnadem, raxs ugar n bnadem, yerna tettif skud imdanen ittwaɣen.
Iɛaḍalen i d-iceddan abrid, wid i d-ittuɣalen d imusnawen, ineflyen, neɣ ibennayen, ad lhin. Wid ur d-ittuɣalen ara, taserdast n umrar i yixeddmen aderwic n yimedyaten ɣef $300 ɣer $700 i ssaɛa, ad walin axeddim-nsen yetwaḥraq deg uchatbot.
Lemkan n tasemriyin tisaḍufin am ufares aɣaranab itefru. Acu i d-yettilin d trad, raxsayen, ḥerren ugar, yerna, i tegnatin ɛadi i d-yettawin tuget n uxeddim, am wayen kan i ittif.
Billable hour yella d aɣilif deg unagraw. AI d alaqay.